This past week,
during a meeting with the Professional Learning Community, and I was able to
discuss the GAME plan, created to strengthen confidence and understanding in
the NETS-T standards. Some of colleagues vented about how integrating
technology into instruction is frustrating and time consuming. It is easy to
admit at times, the frustration and discouragement faced occasionally. However
the second there is an increase in participation and enthusiasm amongst the
students and therefore, the effectiveness of the lesson, I instantaneously
change my mind. Instead, I find myself boasting about the successful lesson of
the day.
As
I continue to monitor my progress through the GAME plan, I began to take into
consideration the advice of my course instructor, Suzanne Lebeau, PhD., as well
as authors: John Ross, PhD., Katherine Cennamo, and Peggy Ertmer’s from the
course text, Technology Integration for
Meaningful Classroom Use: A Standards-Based Approach (2009). It was brought
to my attention, by Dr. Lebeau, “Sometime the tools available to us, as
educators, must be repurposed and used in different ways than they were
originally intended” (personal communication, January, 2013). With this, I
realized I had to modify my action plan.
I revisited my GAME plan and notice I was giving the students too much
freedom and too many choices with the use of technology. For example, I
proposed that I would have students create KWL charts, listen to audio, create
presentations, record themselves on a podcast, contribute to a blog, etc.
Though these are fun and exciting ways to get students engaged and to show off
their creativity side, I had to be realistic. In turn, a new question arose:
Can I have this much going on in my classroom and still provide an effective
lesson for my students?
In
order to address this concern, guidelines need to be set and choices need to be
more controlled on my part. I had mentioned in my previous discussion and blog
that my students would complete a Tic-Tac-Toe board with various activities to
choose from. This board would be more useful if I set each column to read,
“Practice”, “Assessment”, and “Reflection”. The students will be instructed to complete one row of
activities. The students are still provided with a choice, so the only
difference is that I would tell them how to get Tic-Tac-Toe. Another benefit to
this modification is being able to challenge the students in certain areas of
the activities completed. One row may have a more challenging reflection, but
simpler Practice exercise and mid-leveled assessment. These levels of
difficulties could be evenly distributive so it is a fair game.
The
category “Assessment” was included in the board game of activities, in order to
monitor student progress and the progress of the lesson. In this week’s
learning resources, it was mentioned “assessments, overall, provide students
and teachers with feedback for learning and effectiveness of the lesson”
(Cennamo, Ross, Ertmer, 2009). Providing students will a choice, increases
student engagement and confidence (Laureate Education, Inc., 2011). Integrating
Technology into this game board activity helps students to mastery skills, be
creative, monitor success in learning, as well as display and communicate their
understanding on the content. In addition, it assists teachers in gathering data,
monitoring the progress of her students and the lesson, evaluating student
performance and understanding, analyzing and organizing data, and communicating
her findings (Laureate Education, Inc., 2011). As stated before, I have not run
into a problem finding information or any of the resources needed to continue
to carry out my GAME plan. I am still, however, waiting for my Polyvision board
to be fixed. In the meantime, I have been requesting the portable SMARTboard to
use, instead.
Jacquelyn Caliente
References:
Cennamo, K., Ross, J. &
Ertmer, P. (2009). Technology
integration for meaningful classroom
use:
A standards-based approach. (Laureate Education, Inc., Custom ed.). Belmont,
CA:
Wadsworth,
Cengage Learning
Laureate Education, Inc. (Executive
Producer). (2011b) Assessing Student Learning With
Technology [Video webcast]. Retrieved from
Hi Jackie,
ReplyDeleteYou make a great point- providing too many choices in fact leaves students overwhelmed. While giving students some choices can successfully differentiate to accommodate all learners, too much can send teacher and students into technology overload. I had this happen once and it became obvious that something needed to change as several of the digital tools went on the fritz all at once- stressful!
It is true that integrating technology can be frustrating and time consuming but as you mentioned when we take the time and see the results through enhanced learning it makes it all worth while. I was reflecting back to a time when I was teaching and we did not have the technology available that we do today. I still spent a substantial amount of time prepping and trying to make lessons dynamic and interesting for my students. I actually find that technology helps me make this process easier and now I have digital copies that are easy to modify, save and share with colleagues. The other interesting thing about integrating technology is that I am finding it easier to do the more I practice and modify based on reflection.
Thanks so much for sharing your GAME plan progress- I really enjoy reading your posts. I look forward to hearing how things go. Have a great night, Petra
Petra,
DeleteYou are so right! When I first received my Polyvision board, I was honestly overwhelmed. I wanted to do so much with it; Present do now, worksheets, homework, test and quizees, etc. It took me a while to get used to how to use the board, pen, and other features. I did not realize how much the kids and I enjoyed it until the day it broke down on us! The pens were not working, and before you knew it the bulb in the projector went out, as well. I really miss my Polyvision board. I realize now how engaged my students were and how engaged I was while using this interactive technology tool.
I also feel it is convenient to have files or worksheets, plans, etc. digitally. It makes it easy to share with others, work on various items in any location with an Internet connection available and a working outlet.
Thank you for your encouraging words during my frustrating time.
Hi Jackie,
ReplyDeleteI really like your Tic-Tac-Toe activity because there are so many ways you can present diversity in practice, assessment and reflection. On reflection alone, I have learned not just to look at the categories or levels of reflection, but to also look at the expression of student reflection as an option of diversity. You could ask your students to reflect using different tools: paper-based, electronic-based personal or collaborative, video, audio, one to one, then ask which way students preferred to reflect.
What do you think?
Alexi
Oh my goodness. I just wrote an entire response to your post on my iPad and for some reason it will not publish! So frustrating. I am just going to recap quickly.
DeleteI agree with your comment about having the students reflect using different tools. I figured I would put those different elements on the Tic-Tac-Toe board under "assessments". They would be able to choose from reflecting on paper, digitaly, or by audio. I wish I could give the students options like this more often, but I it is difficult. We have two portable MAC carts shared between 100+ teachers, three open computer labs, which always have technical problems, and two other computer labs that are utilized by technology teachers 5 periods throughout the day. As you may be able to tell, it is not realistic for me to have my students on a computer everyday or every week for that matter.
At the start of next year, the students are expected to receive their own personal iPads. I am not sure how I feel about this. It will be GREAT in a perfect world, where there are never technology issues (Internet connections, software updates, glitches, etc). Because my students are in middle school (ages 11-14), they are not the most responsible beings. I fear I will run into many issues when things go wrong.
Do you think I am thinking of the worst? Is it not as bad as I am thinking?
Hi Jackie,
DeleteSorry about the digital technicality you were having with your iPad. Is this the kind of "glitch" you are worried about with your students? (not unavoidable). This happened once to me, and from now on, I first write and save my comments on a Word doc, then cut and paste to the blog.
We have three class sets of iPads, and although we all worry that as these tools travel from one class to the next something will get broken, nothing has happened so far. But the overall benefits your school staff and students will experience through this one-to-one situation will be visible, hopefully through the increased sense of responsibility of the students (taking care of the iPads).
Thanks for sharing your ideas, which are always inspiring!
Alexi
Thanks for the reassurance and YES that is actually the exact "glitch" I am talking about! HaHa Funny how I didn't even notice. Already, I have a different type of glitch going on with my students this past weekend. I gave them an extra credit assignment on IXL.com and I had emails from five different parents about how they child was on for two hours because they kept getting kicked off of the program or the website froze once of twice, etc. I can't win!
DeleteJackie,
ReplyDeleteI also feel frustrated when trying to work with technology and trying to incorporate it into the classroom; almost stressful. As for time, what is that?! I am pretty sure teachers work 14-16 hours of a 24 hour day. I am always running out time. Working for the alternative education building, I get paid hourly. So, as soon as the school day is over my pay stops. All the extra time and effort I put in does not get counted on my paycheck. It's like being stuck between a rock and a hard place. I need to provide for my personal family by working and getting paid, but I also need to provide for my school family by putting in extra hours. How do I balance my time and effort without working myself too hard and missing out on my own personal family? How do I put in my very best when I know I don’t get paid for any outside time? Any advice?
I hope your Polyvision board is fixed soon, I bet it adds a bit of stress to your workday when you don’t have the items you need.
Thanks,
Mandie
Mandie,
DeleteQuite honestly, I have no idea how people with families are teachers now-a-days. I am not a mom yet. I just have a husband and a small one bedroom apartment to take care of. I also have a massage business that I am busy with at least three days a week after school, and occassionally spray perfume at a mall for extra cash.
I just know I love teaching and I am sure you do too, unless you would not be in your position. We are dedicated to our work and our students, which is why we feel a need to do do do and be better at what we do.
Is this your first year teaching? Do you create your lesson plans online?
I will absolutely try to work out whatever is on your mind. I feel overwhelmed at times and know it's great to talk to someone who can empathize.
Jackie,
ReplyDeleteSounds like you made some great discoveries and good decisions based on your reflections. While it has been proven by many researchers that choice is highly important and motivating when teaching and assessing students, too many choices can definitely be overwhelming for both teachers and students. Your decision to focus on fewer technology tools at a time is a great decision. Like you I always feel that more is better but sometimes that is not the case. Technology can be overwhelming at times so fewer good choices of tools are better.
I really loved your tic tac toe activity. It is a great way to differentiate instruction for your students. It allows for just enough choice and an option to express themselves in a variety of ways that help them learn best. You have shared some very insightful thoughts and suggestions that have encouraged me to rethink how I use technology to differentiate my own instruction. Thank you for sharing. Have a great weekend!
Daniela
Daniela,
DeleteThank you so much for your positive thoughts and comments on my blog. Your reassurance that I have made a wise decision to modify my game board is encourging. I am inspired by a few teachers who have unique teaching methods and strategies too, so it is very rewarding to know I too have inspired someone else. Thank you for that. It is a huge compliment to me.
Do you think you would be interested in utilizing the tic tac toe method?